Observed Error

During low-precision training (POL=1), particularly with large output vocabularies (30,000-60,000 words), the final projection layer, converting internal representations to words, frequently exhibits accuracy issues.

Explanation

During the backward pass, the final projection layer accumulates a large number of values (equal to the vocabulary size) for each output, using low-precision 16-bit arithmetic. This extensive accumulation can introduce inaccuracies, hindering convergence. Additionally, the inputs to this layer typically originate from a softmax cross-entropy layer, whose non-normal distribution deviates significantly from the typical normal distributions observed in most layers, further contributing to inaccuracy on the backward pass.

Work around

To mitigate potential convergence issues arising from numerical instability in the final projection layer during low-precision training (POL=1), a per-layer setting of POL=0 should be applied to this specific layer. This ensures the highest numerical precision for the final projection while maintaining the performance advantages of POL=1 throughout the rest of the model. This modification has already been incorporated into the Model Zoo variants of Cerebras large language models.